Hospital Blamed for HIV Stigma
posted: 30/06/2010
The recent publicity and invitation to over 500 patients cared for by a healthcare worker with HIV to have a HIV test at York Hospital has been described as “disgraceful” by one of the city’s leading academics.
Professor David Maughan Brown, deputy vice-chancellor of York St John University, accused NHS bosses of not caring “who they terrify” or “how severely they stigmatise people living with HIV”.
In a letter to The Press, York’s local paper, Prof Maughan Brown questioned the thinking behind the hospital asking 519 patients to undergo HIV tests “because they have come into contact with a hospital worker who is HIV positive”.
Gross over-reaction and HIV stigma
He suggested there had been “a staggeringly inappropriate over-reaction by people so fearful of the risk of litigation, however incredibly remote, that they don’t care who they terrify or how severely they stigmatise people living with HIV”. He claimed the alternative was that senior medical personnel in the UK were so ignorant about the transmission of the HIV virus that they believed it could be passed on by casual contact. “Of the two disgraceful alternatives, one can but hope it is the former,” he said.
Risk ‘very low’
His comments come after the paper revealed last week how 101 former hospital patients in York had received letters asking them to attend HIV testing, after being treated by a member of clinical staff who was found to have HIV. Patients were offered support, counselling and the opportunity to undergo testing, but experts said the risk of cross-infection was very low.
A spokesman for NHS North Yorkshire and York said it would be “inappropriate” to comment on Prof Maughan Brown’s letter, due to an injunction preventing the publication of any information which could lead to the identification of the staff member. However, the trust repeated an earlier statement that only those who had received a letter asking them to undergo testing needed to contact their hospital.
Not one HIV infection from any HIV+ healthcare worker
Thousands of people have been scared across the NHS over the years, but no-one has ever been found with HIV from a NHS healthcare worker. George House Trust believes this was another pointless scare, stigmatising people and HIV. Much of the advice in the cautious NHS guidelines (now 5 years old) seems to have been ignored.
York Hospital's bad record with HIV
Two years ago York Hospital lost 19 people’s HIV medical notes in the street
NHS Guidance: HIV Infected Health Care Workers: Guidance on Management and Patient Notification [July 2005]
Source
Permalink